We look forward to your queries regarding practice and teaching of Music. Every week we shall feature the ones received and seek the helps of experts and our web-audience, visitors to provide a satisfactory explanation. Please click here to send.

30/09/07 Recently, I heard a three-stringed instrument being played at the Thai Cultural Centre in Bangkok. It was brilliant! When I bought one, I was told it was a Vina. Can anyone tell me if it is possible to get sheet music for this instrument?I would be grateful for any help. Thank you.
Glenda Fawkes
 

 

It is wonderful that you have acquired an interesting instrument. The ancient Tri-tantri Veena (literally  three-stringed) is precursor to modern Sitar. But  for almost a millennium now it has not been in use. The three-stringed instrument may be one of the several folk instruments used by Indian folk-artistes like Chikara of Meo or a variant of Sarangi -- Jogiya Sarangi -- or perhaps Surinda. Veena is a generic term used for stringed instruments; it may denote Saraswati Veena after the goddess of learning. If you send us top-view and close-up of bridge, bow etc. it may be possible to identify the instrument.

 

Ome
08/10/07
I am a 25 years old electronic engineer. But I am always living with classical music (Hindustani). I  feel that am a really talented and natural artiste. I want to place my self fully within music study research performing and whatever may be the aspect. Now I am learning from my Respected Guruji. But I want to leave every thing for sadhna. I know I will do it. Because there is no second option. Please tell me whether you have any scope for me or provide any right suggestion........am getting blocked in ... my job ... which is ... burning my time. Please help me. I want to be with music only for food and peace forever.
Rupak Bhattacharyya
 

 

Dear Rupak, you are one of the fortunate ones who have been blessed by Saraswati, on whom Muses shine from all directions. You have not allowed your talent to be blunted by by your study and work. We look forward to one of the rare persons in Indian classical music -- a brilliant sun rather than a twinkling star. This involves great strength of spirit along with natural talent. As an electronics engineer you are sure to affect the stream of Indian music without deflecting its tradition. You should pursue academic courses in Indian Music through distance studies. Bhoj University may offer you one. Else you can seek admission to some college in your city. In case formal education is not possible you should take up musical texts available in regional language and translate them into English and other languages. Such studious activities would keep you secure and protected from the lure of using your talent to other ends. Peace like music is within; you don't have to leave your immediate life to find them. One sublimates oneself in his art; expresses the universal truth without being personal. It is with such constancy that Indian music has been served.

 

Ome
03/10/07

Am deeply moved by the way this website is organised. Am a beginner in sitar. Have learnt a year of sitar. Will getting myself trained voclly in hindustani contribute to my development in sitar?

Meera Govindrajan
 

 

Thanks for your appraisal. An art-form involves understanding of the form and appreciation of the content. You learn the required material of Hindustani music along with techniques of sitar. When a person learns vocal music, she learns techniques to control voice along with similar material, i.e. bandishes in different Raga-s etc. While previous training in vocal music might be of some help, the time taken to master technique of Sitar or other musical instrument remains the same. Listening to vocal and instrumental rendition of the same Raga while one continues to practice on instrument is conducive to learning. If you drop instrument in favour of another or take up vocal, on picking it up again the initial learning blocks would have to be surmounted a second time.

 

Ome
1/10/07

I’m 27 and working. I would like to learn Odissi. Is it too late for me to start? Could you please let me know the details of your institute as to where it is situated and the charges too.

Medha Dutta
 

 

You can learn this art form at any age; however your learning would be limited by physical agility and time available for practice. There are several teachers and institutions for Odissi. You can contact those in your city or ones at convenient locations.

 

Ome
06/09/07

I am doing Ph. D. on the musical instruments of the Indian subcontinent. In this regard, I express my gratitude for providing such an informative site on music.
I am aware that Pt. Lalmani Misra has done a classical research in the field of the classification of the musical instruments with regard to Hindustani classical music. being a blind person, I cannot read his great research but but my PC can read all text for me. I therefore request you to kindly provide the e-text of the relevant material if possible. I have learnt that a translation work is under progress for all works of Dr. Misra. Please do let me know which of the books have been translated and are for sale.

Vedprakash
 

 

Dear Vedprakash, It is a pleasure to learn that this website is able to help you with your doctoral research. It has always been the aim of this website to make available writings of music scholars of modern India so that Indian Classical Music can be studied in proper perspective.

A series on Misrabani compositions for strings planned by Dr. Misra is ready for publication. The translation of Bharatiya Sangeet Vadya and other works is in progress; soon as any book is available it shall be announced on this website. Meanwhile, it shall be our endeavor to post articles and research papers. You may check books listed in the reference section.

 

Ome
21/08/07

Si, I need to find some bandishes for Sitar.

S. Hamid
 

 

There are not many books which deal specifically with compositions for Sitar. Tantri Nad by Dr. Lalmani Misra was the first exhaustive work on style of Indian strings and compostions. Patrick Moutal's Comparative Study of Indian Raga-s and Hindustani Raga-s Index may be helpful. However, Dr. Pushpa Basu's Raga Rupanjali carries almost 300 compositions of Dr. Lalmani Misra specifically meant for Sitar, Sarod, Vichitra Veena etc.

 

Ome
09/08/07

Dear Ome Nad,
I would like to receive some information about the nomination procedure for The Sangeetendu Pandit Lalmani Misra Bal Adhyeta Award as well as the Sangeetendu Pandit Lalmani Misra Yuva Sadhak Award. I think that this is a great idea, and a wonderful tribute to Panditji.

Shawn Mativetsky
 

 

The nomination procedure is simple. Details of the artiste along with supporting documents are forwarded by senior artistes, music scholars, critics or enthusiasts giving reason for their recommendation to the Madhukali Board. To contact Madhukali click here or visit http://www.opchourasiya.com

 

Ome
31/07/07 Please can you tell me if there is any grant for research in music?
Tara Pant
 

 

There are several kinds of grants and fellowships for conducting research activites in music. Ministry of Culture, Govt. of India gives junior and senior fellowships apart from several other grants /scholarships. Tehre are international agencies which also award grants for research in some particular aspect of music. To know more click here.

 

Ome
11/07/07

Dear Omenad,
I have found in several ancient tamil texts like Silappadikaram the instrument yal. But I am not able to find any picture from this instrument. In Silappadikaram there is also written how the girl tuned her yal. I didn`t find any tamil text on music like in sanskrit. Do you know any text and do you know a picture of this instrument? In an book from 1914 there is written the existence of 4 different yals- for each region neydal, kurinci..- on thhis fact the writer built the existenz of 96 srutis in south indian music. After him each yal had 24 strings. If you know any idea where I will find a picture or if possible a yal player today, who play today yal it would be very helpful.

Andreas Leitz
 

 

The period of Tamil music ranges approximately between 300 BC and 3rd AD. Anceint texts like Tolkappiam and Silappadikaram presuemd to be written 2nd century AD or later, talk about music of that period. Tolkappier (author of Tolkappiam) categorized the country into four main regions - Kurinji (hills), Marudam (arable lands), Mullai (pastoral regions) and Neithal (coastal belts). Wasteland or Palai was added later. Each region had its Pann (song), Parai (percussion) and Yazh (harp). Lewis Rowell notes that Yal was sometimes used for Yazh. In the past two millenium the diferent yal-s of these regions evolved as musical instruments . Silappadikaram too uses Yazh as generic name for stringed instrument. The yazh was greatly respected as Madhavi salutes the yazh taking it from Kovalan in the Kanalvari of Silappadikaram. The yazh was played on open strings which were tuned to the notes of absolute pitch. The term “Narambu” indicates that in addition to different types of strings, thick guts must have also been used. Periyazh of 21, Siriyazh with 7 strings are supposedly the most ancient yazh-s. Makarayazh with 17 or 19 strings and Sagodayazh with 14 strings also find mention in ancient texts.

These ancient instruments have evolved differently over the two millenium. Yal or Yazh may be a name given to several folk string instruments but it is not employed for classical music today. Click here to know about evolution of musical instruments.

 

Ome
18/04/07

Dear OME administrators,
I recently came across you web site, and I just wanted to tell you how impressed I am with your collection of resources. I haven't gone through everything yet, but I really am enjoying your site, and the contribution it is making as an online academic resource for Indian classical music. Thank you for this resource, and I look forward to future updates!

Shawn Mativetsky

Tabla & Percussion

 

Dear Shawn, Thanks for your encouraging words. The knowledge about music available in Sanskrit, Hindi and other Indian languages is immense. Scholars in second half of twentieth century have presented ancient knowledge vis-a-vis modern thought. We look forward to contributions on writings of such scholars as Pt. Omkarnath Thakur, Prof. B.R. Deodhar, Acharya Brahspati, Thakur Jaidev Singh, Prof. R.C. Mehta etc. so that second wave of modern music scholarship may evolve. Articles on performing artistes, scholars and teachers are also welcome. Several volumes printed in 19th or early twentieth century have been reprinted by Low Price Publication. Click here for news.

 

Ome
10/04/07

I have a question concerning tuning of instruments. I have read that different pitches affect the chakras differently, and that SA RE GA etc. are associated with the chakras. Are those pitches particularly frequencies, i.e. is a sitar or tambura always tuned to a specific frequency in order to have that effect? Esoteric traditions seem to point to B or C# as having profound effects on the physiology, but I cannot get a straight answer on this from any of the Indian musicians I have spoken with.  

Hoping for some clarification.

 

There is a passing reference to Naadi-s in Sharanagdev's Sangeet Ratnakar. In shloka 1|3.. he refers to 22 naadi-s which in response to diferent force of air give rise to 22 shruti-s. Pandit Omkar Nath Thakur, singer par excellence writes in his Pranav Bharati that at a young age he had heard his father discuss awakaening of Kundalini through Nada but whether these related to 22 musical shruti-s it is difficult to state.

According to Naadbindoopanishad (shloka 36-46) Naad has the great power of uniting the mind with supreme cleansing it of all worldly objects. Hence the aspirant through practise should endeavour to hear this naad within. In the first stage of meditation one hears ocean waves, streams; in the second, Ghanta (large bell), Mardal; in the final state he hears the sound onf Kinkani, Flute, Veena. That the world does not exist, he'd feel when he attains such blending as of milk and water.

There is no medical corroboration of Chakra-Naadi-Kundalini etc. The practices based on these stress upon "looking within". Quite as rules of Newtonian Physics fail in domain of Quantum, the material truth differs from the spiritual truth. You are using material terms (pitch, B or C#) to measure the spiritual (chakra). The discipline of music limited by rules of Newtonian Sound Physics can supply no answers to spiritual queries. Please check out "Measure for Measure".

 

Ome
23/03/07

I have a hard question for you, but it is also a fun one. Is the ancient Rag Hindol the equivalent of  the carnatic rag Amritavarshini? Or of Rag MalaShree? 

Basis for question: 

Rag Hindol in the Rag-Ragini system was known as the main Rag of the Spring season.  This is stated by the school of thought known as the Hanuman Mata and the Bharat Mata.  And these old system decided when to play the Rags by seasons and it seems not by time of day yet ( correct me if I am wrong).  In one book called "Raga Guide", it talks of the ancient Rag Hindol as "an ancient spring raga in which both Re and Dha were omitted. However, from the 16th century onwards, Hindol omits Re and Pa."  So if you take this fact to be true then the old Raga structure matches that of Raga AmritaVarshini.  I really wanted to play the ancient way of playing Rag Hindol, they way it was given by the devotion of Shri Hanuman and Sage Bharat or Bharat the brother of Rama.

Christopher Klacsanzky

 

The question is based on apparent similarities which give rise to false assumptions. Indian music system is based on consonance of notes (as explained in answer to your earlier question of 03/03/07).

The gods, ancient sages and personalities after whom various "mat" or belief have been named -- viz. Shiv-mat, Krishna-mat, Bharat-mat, Hanumat-mat, Ravana-mat -- have little to do with modern Raga system which employs certain distinct practices different from earlier Jaati-gan. So there is no way you can play Hindol "the ancient way", "the way it was given by the devotion of Shri Hanuman and Sage Bharat or Bharat the brother of Rama".

Hindustani Hindol is quite different from Carnatic Hindol which corresponds to Hindustani Malkauns. You may find structural similarity in Amritvarshini but by no logic of Indian music can it be compared to Hindol. The same is true for Malashree. Vimalkant Rai Choudhury speaks of ten Carnatic Raga-s going by name Hindol... Check out article on Hindol.

 

Ome
03/03/07

Is there any universal system for Samay or timing that is used in Indian classical music? The carnatic system of music doesn't seem to have a Samay system and many of the gharanas have different opinions about the timing of Ragas. Also the Vadi and Samvadi for a Raga seems to differ between Gharanas and North and South Indian Music. Is there a universal system for Vadi and Samvadi? Sage Narada, who is well respected in the field on Indian classical music says that "who sings knowing the proper time remains happy. By singing ragas at the wrong time one ill-treats them. Listening to them, one becomes impoverished and sees the length of one's life reduced."

Please tell me your feelings on the Vadi, Samvadi, and Samay system. I am doing research on this topic for a Performing Arts class at Evergreen State College.

Christopher Klacsanzky

 

To begin with you can gain some insight from Time Theory Of Raga-s. Indian music has been practised over a large geographic area and talent has always been able to find a new way of expression. The "universal law" you seek is the samvad siddhanta that accepts sonant-consonant couples situated at distance of 13 shrut-is (Shadja Pancham), 9 shruti-s (shadja madhyam), 7 shruti-s (shadja gandhar) 6 shruti-s (shadja komal gandhar). The first two were given by Bharat, the other two have been accepted by contemporary thinkers. Check out Shruti Veena: Manifestation of Bharat’s Gram and ChatuhSarana for greater understanding of Shruti-s. A particular Raga moves around its sonant note; sometimes a raga may have two notes of equal weightage. It is in such cases that Gharana-s might choose to emphasise one over other. Bhimpalasi, Bhairavi, Nayaki Kanhada, Des are some of the Raga-s of this kind. There always is the possibility of an artiste taking liberty and including notes ordinarily banished in a raga or experimenting with movement of notes. Pt. Bhatkhande made a simple distinction by including all raga-s with prominent sonant in lower tetrachord in the time frame 12 noon to midnight and with prominent sonant in uper tetrachord in time frame from midnight to mid-day. Linking it with natural cycle of sun, Dr. Misra advances the time-slot from four in the evening to four in the morning. Check out article Swar in Sam Veda

 

Ome
03/03/07

I often hear in Gandharva channel on worldspace radio that such and such raga belongs to xyz thhat. I have learnt the same raga in the announced ang. Is there no difference in thaat and ang?

Priya Kandhava

 

There is a definite difference. Worldspace announcers might be making the common error of mistaking "ang" with "thaat". Every Raga employs the twin element of music -- notes and rhythm. There are two classifications possible, both employing notes. The classification based on the structure of notes is called "Thaat" and that employing movement of notes is called "Ang". Bilaskhani Todi because of structure of notes (four flat Re, Ga, Dha, Ni) belongs to Bhairavi Thhat; because of its movement (Sa, Re, Ga, Re, Ga, Re, Sa) it belongs to Todi Ang.

 

Ome
28/02/07

Where can I get advanced lessons in Misrabani?

sitarnow

 

Dear sitarnow, it depends on location. Misrabani compositions were created by Dr. Lalmani Misra for string instruments. Some of his disciples do practise these compositions and are willing to teach, e.g. Dr. Nancy Nalbandian in Philadelphia, Dr. Ragini Trivedi in India. You may also send a request with complete details which shall be forwarded to either of the two.

 

Ome
17/10/06

What is the difference between the 4 types of lyric in Drupad. Gauharbani, Khandarbani, Dagurbani and Naoharbani. Were can I find an explanation and examples for this typs of lyric? If you are able to give me some help if would be very kind of you.

Andreas Leitz

 

The four types of lyrics are named so after the regions where they developed. Gauharbani or Gubarhari is a derivative of Gaurari or Gwaliori. This was the language of Gwalior region where Tansen first wrote his Dhruva-pada-s. Rana Sanga had occupied a fort called Khandar during the times of Babar, hence the few dhrupad-s written in dialect of this region are known as Khandarbani. Dang region near Delhi gave birth to Dangur or Dagurbani. People of Nauhar caste used thier own dialect and their dhrupads were called Nauharbani.

Man Singh, the king of Gwalior promoted Dhruva-pada during 14th century with the aim of translating Sanskrit Prabandha into dialects. Dhruva-pada singers travelled or migrated to nearby places. Years later when their descendents began performing in the court of Akbar, to make a linguistic distinction, the four epithets were used.

Today, there is no documentation available that distinguishes one "-bani" from the other. However linguistic distinctions may still be achieved. There is little musical difference between them apart from that effected by difference in pronounciation, hence they are not distinct styles.

You may refer to Sangeet Chintamani by Acharya Brahaspati, Dhrupad Sameeksha by Bharat Vyas, Tomaron ka Itihaas, Madhya-deshiya Bhasha and Tansen by Harihar Niwas Dwivedi

 

Ome
8/10/06

This query might sound silly at the onset but I am highly curious to know...would appreciate a response!

Is there a technical term associated with a situation where a musician or a singer starts a melody (may be a raag) but leaves it midway...something like a sudden halt in music...the stop is not purposeful ... the musician just left it unfinished.

Priyanka Verma

 

Technically, no. We have consulted several books and experts and though Indian classical musicians have several "dosh" clearly explained, there is no reference to such an activity.
What you are probably pointing at might be caused by two reasons:
1. The singer started off on a scale that he could not carry to the final note and had to leave half-way.
2. The singer got so lost in his emotions that he forgot his responsibilities to the listener and stopped singing.
While the first is lack of proper training and classically such a half-baked artiste would never be allowed to take the stage by his Guru, the second is an example of "personal" art which was never sanctioned in India. An Indian artiste always expresses the ideals of the age / society and hence is never socially irresponsible.
It seems you would have to coin a word for such a situation

 

Ome
15/06/06
It is clearly understood and accepted that the modern Indian Sitar has come from the Iranian seh-tar, a three stringed instrument. On this basis, Indian scholars now speack of it's descent from an Indian three stringed instrument, tri-tantri veena. This is clearly a pathetic and condemnable attempt to claim the glory of classical heritage, when there are no proofs to support their theories.

Col. R.J Singh

Dear Col. Singh, that evolution of Sitar from seh-tar is stated at several places does not alter the truth of its origin. The misconception is only due to our ignorance or belief. There are numerous references which clearly establish that the sitar is, in fact, of pure Indian origin, the foremost being Dr. Lalmani Misra's Bharatiya Sangeet Vadya (Indian Musical Instruments). Although this book published by Bharatiya Jnanpeeth is available only in Hindi at present, an English version is expected soon. Meanwhile, please do take a look at the articles which deal with the origins of veena and sitar.
Ome
20/02/04

Where can i find notations and tanas on specific ragas. what im looking for is combination of swaras to identify the ragas. At the moment im playing raga kafi and i would like to know it even better. thank you

Jesper Frederiksen

 

Dear Jesper, You can find these notations in a book on Indian Music. You can contact Indian Musicological Society, Jambu Bet, Baroda by sending mail to profrcmehta@yahoo.com In the Raga-rang section of this website basic facts about Raga-s are discussed. You can follow the links and learn about notations etc of Kafi

 

Ome
13/08/03
On an All India Radio programme, Sangeet Sarita, broadcast this morning, I heard that stringed instruments like Sitar, Sarod and Santoor have all originated from Rudra Veena. Also, that oldest form of singing is Dhrupad. Are these facts correct?
Rupali Rathore

Dear Rupali, Your doubt is well-grounded. No, neither is the present day Rudra Veena the mother of all instruments, nor is Dhrupad the ancient most form of singing. Sitar has developed from Tritantri Veena, Sarod from Chitra Veena and Santoor from Shat-tantri Veena, exisiting independently of Kinnari Veena. Consult this short article or Bharatiya Sangeet Vadya (Jnanpith, New Delhi, 1973, rprnt: 2003) to know about Indian musical instruments and their origin in more detail.

The oldest form of singing is Jaati-Gaan developed immediately after Sam-gaan. Later it modified into Prabandh-gaan which in turn developed into Dhrupad during 14th century and was so popularised by Raja Man Singh Tomar of Gwalior. Nayak Bakshu, also known as Baiju was a singer in his court and composed Dhrupad in thousands.

Ome
02/08/03

In which century did Khusro invent Sitar?

Neal Jain
Dear Neal, Sitar is the modern name given to a type of Veena. A critique of SharangDev’s Sangeet Ratnakar by Kallinath in 12th century mentions that Tritantri Veena in folk parlance is known as Jantra. Captain Willard in his book Music of Hindostan (1838) stated that according to popular belief Sitar was invented by Amir Khusro. The great poet, musician and inventor Khusro, himself never once mentions inventing Sitar. This false conjecture is based on etymological speculations and folklore -- Khusro removed one “Tar” (string) of four-stringed Veena ending up with “Seh” (three in Persian) “Tar” thereby creating Sitar. Yet if Tritantri Veena has been in existence since Matang (9th Century), how could it have been reinvented by Khusro? ...more>
Ome
08/07/03

Was Sitar a Persian instrument brought to India like Rabab?

Kirstine

Dear Kirstine, your question is a good example of multiple fallacy. Neither was Sitar brought from outside India, nor did Rabab, the Persian instrument develop into modern Sarod. ...more>

Ome
12/05/03

Where can I get notations of rare Ragas like Kukubh Bilawal, Lachha Sakh, Barari, Simhendra, Anand Bhairavi, Godhan Gouri and such like?

Siddhada

Dear Siddhada, your interest in the rarer treasure of Indian music is laudable. However, you have mentioned a few modern Raga-s along with ancient ones considered rare these days. The variegated flavor of Bilawal has been beautifully rendered by Pt. Mallikarjun Mansur and his son and disciple Pt. Rajshekhar Mansur. Kukubh and Shukla Bilawal, Lachha Sakh, Barari, Shivamat Bhairav, Godhan Gouri, Sorath, Adambari Kedar, Basanti Kedar and several other rare masterpieces of these maestros have been released on cassettes and CDs (“In the Footsteps and Beyond”). You can listen to Simhendra Madhyam ( A Raga created by Pt. Ravishankar) on a CD “Pure Joy” released by Sitar prodigy Dr. Chandrakant Sardeshmukh. One of the purest renderings of Raga Gouri on Sitar can be heard on “SHRINGAR – The Magic of Romance” performed by Dr. Gopal Shankar Misra and published by nâda. Gouri, Shree, Manohar, Malgunji, Bageshri-Kanhada, have also been performed by Vicitra Veena virtuoso Dr. Lalmani Misra who also created such Raga-s as Anand Bhairavi, Shyam-bihag, Jog Todi, Madhu-bhairav, Madhukali and Sameshwari.

Ome
09/01/03

I have heard that in Indian music there is relationship between a composition and time it is played... can you throw some light on this?

Claudia

Dear Claudia, Hope our friends are able to give you answers soon. Meanwhile you can go through this article written almost four decades back.

Ome
19/12/02

Under the new syllabus of UGC, the undergraduate courses and PG courses both focus on Music as performing Art. If we have to learn such things as acoustics, recording techniques in a regular university course where shall we be able to learn about the millennium old heritage of Indian Music?

Santosh Pathak

Dear Santosh, You have rightly observed that the suggested syllabi for Indian Universities seems tilted in favour of performance rather than academics. The scientific quest regarding nature and composition, stylistics and sound-cognition-emotion relationship are still valid subjects for academic centers. Hopefully, this is a passing phase and we shall see a revival of academics soon in the national centers of learning. ...more>

Ome

<Recent Queries